Dylan Kerrigan
  • Home
  • About
  • Academic Writings
    • Consultancy Summaries
  • Books
  • Opeds/Blogs
  • Other Writings
  • Teaching
    • Graduate Supervision
  • Therapeutic Cultures
  • In the Press
  • Presentations
  • Videos
  • Research
    • Data Visualisations
    • Past
    • Current
    • Future
  • Blog

The more things change

10/11/2013

0 Comments

 
_Power in the past and power in the present look a lot alike
Picture
Errol Fabien suggested on Monday that we have lost the bar by which we measure governments and politicians. It’s a sensible statement most might accept as a matter of fact, but is it so simple as loss?

One of the things anthropologists are trained to do is compare different societies and cultures. We call this “ethnology.” Some might think comparisons necessitate a sort of league table of better or worse societies, like the happiness and corruption indexes or GDP figures produce. Those sort of hierarchal measurements however tell us very little about changing sociocultural values and conventions.

A better form of cultural comparison eliminates hierarchy and tries to produce empathy. Empathy is the effort of imagining and trying to understand being stood in someone else’s shoes. It is a hallmark of good ethnological studies.

Anthropologists don’t just do ethnology of societies in the present; we also make these comparisons historically. For example, you can represent the ideas, values and culture behind measuring the success or failure of a government in the past, with the ideas, values and cultures of measuring success or failure in the present.

Someone closely associated with this line of social science was Michel Foucault. He believed that you could make connections between discourses in the present and discourses in the past – a sort of genealogy or archaeology of ideas.

Dr Hollis Liverpool likes to remind people that calypsonians were the original anthropologists of Trinidad and Tobago. One of the most famous Drs of this art, the Mighty Sparrow, wrote a calypso in 1967 about corruption in government and what the population thought about it.

He identified in lyrics a lot of elements the social scientist would call discourse - values, ideas and conventions. For example, to tell us about the sometime criminal behaviour of politics, he either used the following exact words or ones very similar: “fakes and phonies”, the victimisation of those who criticise, “corruption throughout the country”, who should be arrested is protected and respected, double-deals as idols, violations of the law, and a new economic slavery.

“Discourse” can be understood as the ideas, values, ideologies, language and general social information surrounding and supporting the production of a particular way of seeing the world. So there is a discourse around politics, a discourse of law, a discourse of education and so on.

These discourses structure what a society in all its different social spaces and at different times deems proper or improper. What can be said and what can’t. We are all socialised and educated by such discourses because we are born into them, they exist before we do, and they influence the possibilities of social change throughout our lives.

In colonial times the success and failure of government was measured by political discourse that adhered to the interests, values and worldview of the Metropolitan centre. Up until 1945 it was do as I say, not as I do, and do it for Mother Britain. We were run and told what to do by a small male cabal and elite. Not completely different to how some describe the situation today.

To move to Independence, the ideas, values and culture of our society, as well as the inter-national discourse about Colonialism had to shift. What was sayable and doable in the Colonies needed reframing. The opportunity for Independence movements was impossible until little by little a discourse of Creole nationalism emerged out of the discourse of Colonialism.

In the post independence period things were meant to be different and they were to a degree. As Eric Williams mentioned, the “division of the races…separation and fragmentation were the policy of colonialism.” And maybe we might suggest that for Williams, measuring success would include moving away from such racial division.

Yet while race hierarchy as a discourse started to be dismantled, it never really vanished. Rather it morphed to divisions of class, infused with race, and ethnic hierarchy. And of course in the Caribbean whether its local or international politics we know the legacies of racial hierarchy were never totally removed.

The separation and fragmentation of colonialism became our tribal politics. While instead of empathy for slavery, colonialism and Independence our small island nations got UN, IMF and World Bank rankings.

So in answer to Mr Fabien’s observation we might suggest he’s noticed not just the absence of measurement but also a failure of political and social systems to change greatly. They might look different from the outside but a genealogy of ideas betrays the changes. Yes things change, but as the saying goes, the more they stay the same.

http://guardian.co.tt/columnist/2013-11-10/more-things-change
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Categories

    All
    Academia
    Amerindian
    Bias
    Capitalism
    Carnival
    Census
    Change
    Charlotteville
    Christmas
    Cipriani
    Citizenship
    Class
    Clico
    Colonialism
    Comedy
    Community
    Conspiracy
    Corruption
    Crime
    Critical Thinking
    Cultural Logic
    Cultural Logic
    Cultural Myth
    Culture
    Degradation
    Development
    Differences
    Disabilities
    Discourse
    Discrimination
    Diversity
    Division
    Drugs
    Economic
    Economics
    Economy
    Education
    Emancipation
    Emigration
    Employment
    Environment
    Equality
    Ethnicity
    Ethnocentrism
    Ethnology
    Family
    Gang
    Gender
    Governance
    Government
    Grenada
    Hcu
    History
    Homophobia
    Identity
    Imperialism
    Inequality
    Institutions
    Intellectualism
    Justice
    Language
    Legislation
    Marriage
    Mas
    Militarism
    Military
    Morality
    Multiculturalism
    National Security
    Nepotism
    Opportunity
    Patriarchy
    Policy
    Politics
    Poverty
    Power
    Precolonial
    Prejudice
    Prisons
    Privatisation
    Privilege
    Progress
    Propaganda
    Prostitution
    Race
    Reflexivity
    Relationships
    Religion
    Rights
    Science
    Security
    Segregation
    Sexism
    Sexuality
    Sex Work
    Slavery
    (small-goal) Football
    Social Media
    Soe
    Solidarity
    Speed
    State
    Status
    Success
    Taboo
    Teaching
    Technology
    Tobago
    Tourism
    Trade
    Transparency
    University
    Violence
    War
    White Collar
    White-collar

    Archives

    December 2022
    October 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    August 2020
    June 2020
    March 2020
    January 2020
    February 2019
    November 2017
    October 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012

    RSS Feed